Will Your Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident? Rates, Surcharges and Accident Forgiveness
An at-fault accident can raise your premium for years. Here is how insurers decide surcharges, how long they last, when accident forgiveness helps and how to bring your rate back down.
Updated November 19, 2026 · 3 min read
After an accident, the first worries are safety and repairs. The next one is often money: will your car insurance go up, and by how much? The answer depends mainly on who was at fault, the size of the claim, your driving history, your state’s rules and your insurer’s own pricing.
- At-fault accidents usually raise premiums, often for three to five years.
- Not-at-fault accidents generally should not raise rates as much, and some states restrict surcharges for them.
- Accident forgiveness, safe-driver discounts and shopping around can soften or reverse the increase.
At-fault versus not-at-fault
Insurers price risk. An accident where you were mainly responsible suggests a higher chance of future claims, so it usually leads to a surcharge at renewal. Many studies of insurer pricing show that a single at-fault accident with an injury or significant damage can raise premiums by a substantial percentage, though the exact amount varies widely.
When another driver was clearly at fault and their insurer pays, your rate is less likely to rise. Several states have laws limiting surcharges for accidents where you were not at fault. Comprehensive claims, such as hail damage or hitting a deer, generally have less effect than at-fault collisions, though frequent claims of any type can matter.
How long an accident affects your rate
Most insurers look back three to five years when setting rates. The surcharge usually decreases as the accident ages and disappears after that period, provided you have no new incidents. The accident may also appear on your state driving record and in insurance claims databases, such as the CLUE report that many insurers check.
Also readUninsured and Underinsured Motorist Coverage: Why It Matters More Than You ThinkAccident forgiveness
Accident forgiveness means your insurer will not raise your rate after your first at-fault accident. It may be:
- Earned automatically after several years without claims with the same insurer
- Bought as an add-on for an extra premium
- Included in certain premium packages
Read the details. Forgiveness usually applies only to the first accident, may not transfer if you switch insurers and is not available in every state.
Should you file a claim for a small accident?
For minor damage, some drivers pay out of pocket to avoid a claim on their record. This can make sense if the repair cost is only slightly above your deductible. But be careful:
- Always report accidents involving injuries or other drivers to your insurer, as policies require prompt notice. Injuries can appear days later.
- If another person is involved, they may file a claim against you anyway.
- Get a repair estimate before deciding.
How to lower your rate after an accident
- Shop around at renewal. Insurers weigh accidents differently, and a new insurer may offer a much better price.
- Take a defensive driving course. Some states and insurers offer discounts for approved courses.
- Raise your deductible if you have savings to cover it.
- Bundle policies, such as home and auto, for a multi-policy discount.
- Try usage-based insurance. Telematics programmes reward safe driving habits with discounts.
- Review coverage on older cars. Dropping collision on a low-value car can offset the surcharge.
- Keep a clean record from now on; rates fall as the accident ages.
Typical factors in a surcharge
| Factor | Effect on premium |
|---|---|
| Fault | At-fault accidents have the biggest impact |
| Claim size | Larger payouts usually mean larger increases |
| Injuries | Bodily injury claims weigh heavily |
| Prior record | Second incidents raise rates further |
| State rules | Some states limit surcharges |
| Insurer | Each company has its own rating plan |
An accident can make insurance more expensive for a while, but it is not permanent. Compare quotes, use the discounts available and let time and safe driving rebuild your record.
This article is general information, not legal, insurance or financial advice. Laws, rates and requirements vary by state and change over time, and examples mainly reflect the United States. Check with your insurer, lender, state agency or a licensed attorney.





