Skip to content
9+9PlusAuto

Lemon Laws Explained: What to Do If Your New Car Keeps Breaking Down

If your new car has a serious defect that the dealer cannot fix after several attempts, state lemon laws may entitle you to a replacement or refund. Learn how they work and how to build your case.

9+
9Plus Auto Editorial Team
Updated November 19, 2026 · 3 min read
Lemon Laws Explained: What to Do If Your New Car Keeps Breaking Down

Buying a new car should mean years of trouble-free driving. Occasionally, though, a car has a serious defect that keeps coming back despite repeated repairs. Every US state has a “lemon law” that gives buyers of qualifying vehicles the right to a replacement or refund when the manufacturer cannot fix certain problems within a reasonable number of attempts.

Key takeaways

  • Lemon laws generally cover new vehicles with substantial defects under warranty that are not fixed after a reasonable number of attempts.
  • Typical tests include several repair attempts for the same defect or many days out of service, within a set period.
  • Detailed records are essential, and many lemon laws require the manufacturer to pay your attorney fees if you win.

What counts as a lemon

Each state defines it differently, but common elements are:

  • A substantial defect that impairs the car’s use, value or safety, not a minor rattle or cosmetic issue
  • Covered by the manufacturer’s warranty
  • Reported within a certain period, often the first 12 to 24 months or a set number of miles
  • Not fixed after a reasonable number of attempts

Common “reasonable attempts” tests

Test Typical rule in many states
Repeated repairs Several attempts (often three or four) for the same defect
Serious safety defect Fewer attempts, sometimes one or two
Days out of service A cumulative number of days in the shop, often around 30

These are general patterns. Check your state’s exact law, as the details vary significantly.

Used and leased cars

Most state lemon laws focus on new vehicles, but many also cover leased cars, and some cover used cars, especially while they are still under the original warranty. A few states have separate used car lemon laws. The federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act can also provide remedies for breach of written warranties on both new and used vehicles.

Also readDiminished Value Claims: Getting Paid for Your Car’s Lost Resale Value

How to build a strong case

  1. Report the problem promptly to an authorised dealer.
  2. Get a written repair order every time, even if the dealer says they could not find a problem. Check that it describes your complaint accurately, the date and the mileage.
  3. Keep everything: purchase contract, warranty, repair orders, receipts, rental car costs and correspondence.
  4. Keep a log of when the problem happens, with photos or videos if possible.
  5. Notify the manufacturer in writing. Many states require direct written notice to the manufacturer, giving it a final chance to repair.
Get it in writingA problem described verbally but missing from repair orders may not count toward the repair attempts. Always ask for written documentation before leaving the dealership.

Arbitration

Many manufacturers run informal dispute resolution or arbitration programmes. Some states require you to use them before going to court. Decisions may be binding on the manufacturer but not on you. Read the rules carefully.

What you may receive

  • Repurchase: a refund of the purchase price, taxes and fees, often minus a reasonable allowance for the miles you drove before the problem began
  • Replacement: a comparable new vehicle
  • Cash and keep: a settlement where you keep the car and receive compensation

Many state lemon laws require the manufacturer to pay your attorney fees if you win. That is why many lemon law attorneys offer free consultations and take cases without upfront fees.

Deadlines

Lemon law rights have time limits, both for when the defect must first appear and for when you must file a claim. Act promptly once a pattern of repairs develops.

A car that spends more time in the shop than on the road is more than an inconvenience. Keep detailed records and learn your state’s lemon law, so you can enforce your rights if the manufacturer cannot fix it.

This article is general information, not legal, insurance or financial advice. Laws, rates and requirements vary by state and change over time, and examples mainly reflect the United States. Check with your insurer, lender, state agency or a licensed attorney.

Read nextHow to Ship a Car Across the Country: Costs, Options and Avoiding Scams

More stories